This old dresser got a makeover and now it’s the perfect farmhouse dresser with a beautiful chippy paint finish created using Old-Fashioned Milk Paint.
It’s furniture flippin time again! So not only do I have a fun dresser makeover to share, my fellow Furniture Flippers are also sharing their latest furniture redos at the bottom of this post.
When I found this old dresser at an estate sale, it was love at first sight. I could tell it was at least 100 years old and had beautiful proportions. But it was also filthy, missing some of the hardware, and just very, very tired. Apparently the sellers didn’t see the potential I saw, because they sold it to me for the bargain price of $12. Sold!
When I got it home, it quickly became apparent just how incredibly filthy this little dresser was and there was also some damage to the top. The poor thing looked like it hadn’t been loved in decades and clearly needed help. I decided to give it a makeover that would embrace it’s age and history rather than fighting against it. I wanted to bring it back to life and give it a beautiful chippy paint finish. I wanted this dresser to look like it had seen many years of use and love, completely unlike the sad, lonely state I actually found it in.
I’ve been wanting to experiment with Old Fashioned Milk Paint for awhile and I knew this dresser was the perfect piece. In case you aren’t familiar with milk paint, it is a vintage style furniture paint made from milk protein along with other completely natural, safe ingredients. Furniture painters love milk paint because it gives a very authentic vintage look to painted pieces of furniture. Furniture that was painted over 100 years ago was pretty much always painted with milk paint and furniture painted with milk paint today most closely matches that look.
When painting raw wood, milk paint actually absorbs into the wood, while most other paints simply coat the surface. Milk paint is also the absolute best way to recreate an aged, chippy paint effect.
This post contains affiliate links which means if you make a purchase after clicking a link I will earn a small commission but it won’t cost you a penny more. Click here to see my full disclosure policy.
Materials for this Dresser Makeover
Cup and plastic fork for mixing the paint
220 grit sandpaper
For the dresser top:
How to Paint a Chippy Farmhouse Dresser
The first step to any furniture makeover is to remove the hardware and clean the piece well. I often just use a mix of Dawn dish soap and water for cleaning furniture, but this dresser was so filthy, I knew I would probably need something more heavy duty.
I bought my Old-Fashioned Milk Paint at my local Woodcraft store. The gentleman helping me was super knowlegable and recommended I try Krud Kutter Prepaint Cleaner before painting so I gave it a try. I love that, unlike many other cleaners, you don’t have to rinse it off before painting. I’m glad I used a more heavy duty cleaner this time, because it was truly amazing how much dirt and grime came off this dresser.
I also decided to remove the old top at this point. The top was made of multiple strips of wood and had some major cracking and swelling issues.
Even after all of the cleaning I did, I still didn’t feel 100% confident it was completely clean, so I also lightly sanded the dresser to be totally sure I was starting with a fresh surface.
Finally it was time for paint! Old-Fashioned Milk Paint and other milk paints don’t come in liquid form like typical paints. They come in powder form and must be mixed with water to create the paint. It’s very simple to do. I used a plastic cup and plastic fork to mix my paint. (You could also use a glass jar and regular fork to be a bit more environmentally friendly.)
The milk paint comes with instructions that recommend a 1:1 ration of paint to water. I found it easiest to add my powder to the cup and then slowly add a little water at a time until it seemed like a good paint consistency. Then stir with the fork until most of the lumps of powder are dissolved into the liquid. If you find your paint is a bit too runny, you can add a bit more powder. If it is too thick and doesn’t glide on smoothly, add a bit more water.
Milk Paint comes in a limited color palette, but it is very easy to mix together to make new colors. To create the color I was going for, I mixed Old Fashioned Milk Paint in Sea Green (love this color!) and Oyster White. It was still a touch too green, and I happened to have a sample of Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint in French Enamel stashed away so I added a tiny bit of that as well. The two brands of milk paint mixed together beautifully and I ended up with the perfect color.
When painting old furniture with milk paint, you may choose to add a bonding agent to help the paint adhere to the old finish. Using a bonding agent like Old-Fashioned Milk Paint’s extra bond will help make sure the paint adheres well and doesn’t flake off. But if you want some of the paint to flake off for that gorgeous old chippy paint look, you can skip the bonding agent.
I chose to paint my dresser without the bonding agent. I love the chippy, aged paint finish milk paint can give and I thought it would be the perfect fit for my old dresser.
You do not need to use primer with milk paint, so once my paint was mixed, I painted the first coat. The first coat of any paint doesn’t usually look great and this is especially true with milk paint. The first coat of paint went on looking very thin and streaky, but thankfully I knew to expect that and didn’t panic.
It’s a good idea to seal your milk paint with a lid or some plastic wrap and keep it in the refrigerator between coats of paint. Milk paint is sold in powder form rather than as a liquid, because once it is mixed into a liquid it can spoil just like regular milk. And like milk, it can last in the fridge for several days this way without going bad.
After letting the paint dry thoroughly, I painted a second and a third coat. I probably could have gotten by with just two coats of paint, but I wanted to make sure I got good, even coverage everywhere.
Once the paint was dry, I was excited to see chipping happening all over the place. I was also a little bit nervous. Usually I distress furniture by sanding it and I am in control of where and how much paint I remove. Milk paint is a whole different animal. It chips wherever it decides and however much it chooses and you have no absolutely zero control.
My dresser was chipping all over like crazy. Way more than I probably would have chosen if I was in charge. But then again, I guess it was a good exercise for a perfectionist like me in just letting go and seeing what happens.
When the paint was completely dry, I used my 220 grit sandpaper to VERY gently wipe the chipped paint away. I didn’t have to truly sand anything and could have probably just used a rag or paper towel to gently knock off the paint that had already chipped.
Then I sealed the entire piece with two coats of General Finishes Flat Out Flat Topcoat. Milk paint always needs to be sealed with a good sealer. Without a sealer, the paint will show water spots if anything drips on it and isn’t wipeable. The sealer will also protect the paint from chipping off further or scratching off. Flat Out Flat is my favorite topcoat for pieces with a vintage look. It is incredibly easy to apply, gives a completely matte finish, and is very durable. (You can read more about my favorite sealers for painted furniture right here.)
Then it was time to figure out the dresser top. I had originally planned to just cut a new top, but I kept looking at the boards from the old top and thinking how beautiful they were. (I’m not the only one who finds old wood beautiful right?) So I came up with a better idea that would make the most of the original wood.
I sanded down the old wood top as best I could to get rid of the stains and white spots. (I’m not sure what the original finish was but it didn’t want to go easily!) Then I simply rearranged the order of the boards. The old top was made of four different planks of wood and only one of them was noticeably warped and damaged. So I simply moved the damaged board to the very back against the wall where it wasn’t very noticeable.
I stained the boards using Minwax Stain in the color Provincial and then sealed it with General Finishes High Performance Top Coat. (I could have used the Flat Out Flat again, but I wanted the wood to have a slight sheen.)
Then I simply nailed the top back to the base, the same way it was attached before.
And finally, the hardware. I considered changing the hardware for something a bit simpler. But I really loved the original hardware; it was part of what drew me to this little dresser to begin with. I know those old pulls may not be as popular right now as simple bin pulls, but they are authentic. And if they’ve lasted this long, it really doesn’t seem right for me to toss them in favor of the latest thing. There was the issue of one handle being missing though.
I did a bit of research online and found a nearly identical match. Of course when it came, it was shiny new brass and looked completely out of place. There was a bit of a crazy mishap with the replacement drawer pull when I attempted to use a chemical reaction to darken the finish and things went very wrong, but I’ll save that story for another day.
Luckily it wasn’t too hard to use a bit of dark brown paint to tone down the color and now I’d bet money you couldn’t tell which drawer pull is the one I painted.
And here she is: my chippy farmhouse dresser.
She’s way more chippy than I originally imagined , but I’m okay with that. I love how this dresser doesn’t look like it was just painted in 2019. It looks like it could have been pulled straight out of an old abandoned house looking exactly like this. And I think she is going to look perfect mixed with a few more streamlined pieces in the master bedroom makeover I am wrapping up.
Here’s one last before and after – this lady really came a long way!
Now be sure to head over and check out the latest furniture makeovers from the rest of The Furniture Flippers. I’m always inspired by the pieces they share!
- Repainting Furniture with the Best Furniture Paint that Will Save You Time by Just the Woods
- How to Bring Old Furniture Back to a Natural Wood Finish by Refresh Living
- Farmhouse Dresser with Old Fashioned Milk Paint by Lovely Etc.
- How to Mix Ombre Paint by A Fresh Squeezed Life